Provisions of Special Rules in the House: An Example of a Typical Open Rule

Provisions of Special Rules in the House:
An Example of a Typical Open Rule
Judy Schneider
Specialist on the Congress
Government and Finance Division
This report includes a typical example of a simple open rule that the House
Committee on Rules may report to govern House floor action on a bill that is not
otherwise privileged for consideration. This resolution has been divided into five parts.
See [] for more information on
legislative process.
The first part of the rule makes the bill in order for floor consideration by authorizing
the Speaker to transform the House into the Committee of the Whole to consider that bill.
Without this authority, a motion for the same purpose would not be in order; it would not
be privileged to interrupt the regular daily order of business on the House floor.
The second part waives a reading of the bill. It also governs general debate on the
bill by setting the amount of time for the debate, by dividing control of this time, usually
between the chairman and ranking minority member of the committee that reported the
bill, and by requiring that all general debate be relevant to the subject of the bill.
The third part merely states that the bill shall be read for amendment and that each
Member may speak for five minutes on each amendment. By implication, this part also
means that the bill is to be read for amendment one section at a time. Further, as each
section is read, Members may offer to it whatever amendments they wish, so long as those
amendments satisfy the House’s rules and precedents — for example, the requirement that
amendments must be germane. This part is what makes this special rule an open rule; it
leaves the bill fully open to amendments that otherwise would be in order.
The fourth part provides for the Committee of the Whole, after disposing of the last
amendment, to transform itself back into the House, and report the bill to the House with
whatever amendments the Committee of the Whole adopted. This provision eliminates
the need for the House to vote on a motion to achieve the same result. The Committee
of the Whole does not vote on the bill as a whole, and the committee may not actually
amend the bill; it only makes recommendations to the House about amendments.
The fifth and final part of the rule expedites final House passage of the bill by
precluding almost all debate in the House and all other actions except those necessary for
the House to vote on the amendments the Committee of the Whole recommended and to

dispose of one motion to recommit the bill to a standing committee. That motion to
recommit may include instructions containing a proposed amendment to the bill.
A Typical Open “Rule”